WW II History - pay attention, class...
(Can anyone provide reliable information to verify, refute or expand upon this info?
-- if so, please email me.
Thanks, jw)
From John Arterbury. Lt. General Lesley McNair was killed by accidental Allied bombing in France (ie: 'friendly fire'). Cite: Crusade by Rick Atkinson
Further, from Captain Robert A. Lynn, The highest ranking U.S. general killed by enemy fire was Lt. General Simon Bolivar, Jr. He was junior to Lt. General Lesley J. McNair, who was killed by U.S. bombers.
Rodney writes: "Highest-Ranking US Army officer killed in WW2 was Simon Bolivar Buckner, a 4-star General. He certainly outranked 3-star Lieutenant-General Lesley J. McNair, highest-ranking US Army officer who died in the ETO. Anyway, being bumped off by your own side doesn't really count; Buckner was actually killed by Japanese shellfire."
David M adds: "The USMC general killed on Okinawa was Gen. Simon Bolivar Buckner. He was killed by artillery shrapnel while observing from a forward position."
The item above was confirmed by a note from Richard Graham of Canton, TX who says: The story about Calvin Graham enlisted in the navy at the age of 12 is a true story. he was a cousin of mine. The last time I talked to Calvin was at a family reunion several years before his death.
Dave Walker writes: Insignia of the 45th Infantry Division. The 45th Infantry Division gained its nickname, "Thunderbird" division, from the gold thunderbird. This Native American symbol became the division's insignia in 1939. It replaced another previously used Native American symbol, a swastika, that was withdrawn when it became closely associated with the Nazi party.
David M adds: "About the 30 mission tour that the Army Air Corps flyers had to fly during WW2. It had been 25 missions until late in the war when the tour was lengthened to 30. Flyers were "grandfathered" based on their enlistment/draft dates."
Bill Talbott, Major, USMC (Ret) offers some interesting Discussion of Aircraft Kill Claims.
According to Bill Douglas, the Me-264 was a prototype that never went into production. Although the design was theoretically possible of a mission to New York, there was never an operational aircraft to test the theory. One reason for canceling the project was that Hitler felt the isolated bombing of New York would do more to rile the US public against Germany than any damage that was achieved.
According to Captain Robert A. Lynn, the Me-264 V-1 DID FLY on 23 December 1942 but the Me-264 V-2 was destroyed in an air raid. The Ju-290 was the designated mid-air refueler for the Me-264. There was no loss of effort on the Germans part but the project suffered from the following: shortage of design and construction capacity, personal rivalries between Goring, Milch, and Messerschmitt, and shortage of production capacity. An air raid on 18 July 144 on Memmingen destroyed the Me-254 V-1 as well as parts of the V-3 and V-4. (cite: Hitler's Miracle Weapons-Volume 1: The Luftwaffe and Kriegsmarine by Friedrich George)
The U-120 was scuttled by her own crew on 2 May 1945 at Bremerhaven, Germany during Operation REGENBOGEN. Info from Captain Robert A. Lynn, Robert Bogash and uboat.net: U-120.
According to this thread, it wasn't U-120 that was lost this way, it was uboat.net: U-1206 (KL Karl-Adolf Schlitt), though there were other issues involved too. The story and more details of this incident and of U-boat toilets are included below.
The Graf Spee did sink when scuttled, but only in waters less than 25 ft deep. It was not bought as scrap by the British, and in fact lay in the silt in the River Plate estuary in Uruguay. An effort is being made to raise her to turn her into a ship museum. See "Salvage Team Prepares to Raise WWII Ship" for more details of her sinking and the recovery effort. (Thanks to Lewis Perelman for the info)
From John Arterbury. Invasion of Kiska deaths were all due to friendly fire. The correct numbers are 28 Americans dead and four Canadian dead. Cite: Canadian Heroes - The Battle for Kiska. Note: this article is fascinating, and says "It was the Battle of Kiska that would lead Time magazine to create the acronym, JANFU (joint army-navy foul-up)."
According to Captain Robert A. Lynn, PAO, Florida Guard, in addition to the men KIA by friendly fire, 50 men were WIA from friendly fire while another 130 suffered trench foot.
Mark Anderson wrote: "In regards to the duel of two spotter aircraft doing battle during the last days of WW2, Cornelius Ryan wrote of the incident in his book Last Battle. While enroute to scout the area around Berlin Lts. Duane Francies and William Martin, in the last "dogfight" between Americans and Germans in WW2, took on a Fieseler "Storch" under pistolfire from their L-4 Cub, forced the Storch to crash land and its two occupants to be captured by an American troop convoy which had watched the action from below. The above account was also verified to me by correspondence from Mr. Martin in 2003."
Further, from Captain Robert A. Lynn, PAO, Florida Guard, The highest ranking U.S. general killed by enemy fire was Lt. General Simon Bolivar, Jr. He was junior to Lt. General Lesley J. McNair, who was killed by U.S. bombers.
Rodney writes: "Highest-Ranking US Army officer killed in WW2 was Simon Bolivar Buckner, a 4-star General. He certainly outranked 3-star Lieutenant-General Lesley J. McNair, highest-ranking US Army officer who died in the ETO. Anyway, being bumped off by your own side doesn't really count; Buckner was actually killed by Japanese shellfire." (sent 5/2006)
David M adds: "The USMC general killed on Okinawa was Gen. Simon Bolivar Buckner. He was killed by artillery shrapnel while observing from a forward position." (sent 5/2006)
I've also heard from the son of a B-24 pilot from the bombing mission that accidently killed General McNair. He mentions that this mission was portrayed on a History Channel "Military Blunders" episode, which matched his father's story of the incident. (sent 4/2004)
According to Captain Robert A. Lynn, PAO, Florida Guard, the Me-264 V-1 DID FLY on 23 December 1942 but the Me-264 V-2 was destroyed in an air raid. The Ju-290 was the designated mid-air refueler for the Me-264. There was no loss of effort on the Germans part but the project suffered from the following: shortage of design and construction capacity, personal rivalries between Goring, Milch, and Messerschmitt, and shortage of production capacity. An air raid on 18 July 144 on Memmingen destroyed the Me-254 V-1 as well as parts of the V-3 and V-4. (cite: Hitler's Miracle Weapons-Volume 1: The Luftwaffe and Kriegsmarine by Friedrich George)
According to this thread,
it wasn't U-120 that was lost this way it was the U-1206 (KL Karl-Adolf Schlitt).
Here is the story of the killer toilet:
"Every U-boat, except midget craft, had a toilet, with the larger types even having two, but one of them was usually used as a larder and therefore could not accommodate the crew until they had passed the contents through the other one. All U-boats had a so-called 'upper deck toilet' as men just urinated over the side. Of course, this luxury could not be used when the boat was submerged and once deeper than about 25m the interior toilet had to be closed as well because the water pressure outside the boat was too great to pump the contents out. This was hardly an imposition at the beginning of the war, but longer dives became the order of the day as the anti-U-boat measures became more ferocious, with boats in the Mediterranean and in American waters regularly remaining submerged for periods of 24 hours or so and special, high-pressure thunder boxes had to be installed. After all a functional 'head' could make all the difference between total and partial concentration.The operation of this high-pressure toilet proved to be so difficult that men with a technical aptitude were specially trained to learn the intricacies of the new weapon. There was a delicate naval term for these men, and the term 'Toilet Graduate' will probably suffice in English. At least one boat, U1206 (KL Karl-Adolf Schlitt), was lost as a direct result of mishandling this complicated 'thunder box'. Kptlt Schlitt tried the system for himself but the LI sent a toilet graduate to help, and somehow with two minds on the same job, the levers were pulled in the wrong order and the commander's offering plus a thick jet of salt water was squirted into their faces. Seeing what had happened, the LI took the boat up to relieve the pressure, but some of the inflowing water drained into the batteries below to produce poisonous chlorine gases (chlorine is produced when salt from sea water reacts with acid in the batteries) and eventually, after an attack from aircraft, the boat had to be abandoned."
Source: Showell, Jak P. Mallmann. U-Boats Under the Swastika. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press, 1987. ISBN: 0-87021-970-7. Copyright: Jak P. Mallmann Showell, 1987.
Additional info and confirmation
According to Captain Robert A. Lynn, PAO, Florida Guard, in addition to the men KIA by friendly fire, 50 men were WIA from friendly fire while another 130 suffered trench foot.